Refine Search
Map
Sort by
$225,000
2026037664 MLS
Fabulous Opportunity! Rarely offered! Build your North Captiva Island getaway on this desirable homesite within Safety Harbor Club, complete with a Class A Membership and access to an outstanding collection of island amenities. Ideally positioned near the heart of the community, the lot is convenient to the remodeled heated pool, clubhouse, tennis and pickleball courts, with the potential for lake views from the upper levels of a fantastic future residence and/or vacation home. For boating enthusiasts, one of the standout benefits is access to Safety Harbor Club’s shared docking facilities, providing options for small and large boats with dockage that can accommodate much larger vessels than most individual island slips. With two docking options - the community wharf and the T-dock plus the community kayak launch there are even more ways to enjoy North Captiva by water! Membership provides access to the community’s Gulf beach access, beach parking, boat dockage, pool, clubhouse, recreational facilities and other amenities, along with water, sewer and trash service. The club’s ferry landing and waterfront restaurant are also conveniently nearby. With key community infrastructure already established, building here may offer advantages compared with developing in other areas of the island. Create the island home you’ve envisioned and enjoy boating, kayaking, beach days, swimming, tennis, pickleball and waterfront dining as part of everyday life. This is a distinctive opportunity to own and build within one of North Captiva Island’s established amenity-rich communities.

4486 Hammock Court, Captiva
$130,000
2026033871 MLS
CASTAWAY KEY ISLAND LIVING STARTS HERE. This homesite on Upper Captiva offers the perfect opportunity to build your own private island retreat in the desirable Castaway Key community. Surrounded by the natural beauty and relaxed atmosphere that make Upper Captiva so special, this lot provides an ideal setting for a custom full time residence, vacation getaway, or investment property. Enjoy the unique island lifestyle with beautiful Gulf beaches, boating, fishing, shelling, and unforgettable sunsets all close by. With its tropical surroundings and peaceful setting, this property is a blank canvas ready for your vision. Build the home you have been dreaming of and create your own slice of paradise in Castaway Key on Upper Captiva.

4520 Smugglers Drive, Captiva
$1,495,000
3 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 2026027022 MLS
Steps to the incredible Captiva Island beach, this fabulous beach cottage features a screened pool and plenty of space for you and your guests. Located at the end of a private shell drive, the beach is just steps away. This elevated home has a metal roof and screened lanai. With "white box" finishes this is your opportunity to create the beach cottage of your dreams. Much of the new plumbing, electrical, insulation, ductwork, drywall and flooring are complete. The restaurants and shops of the Captiva Village are nearby and enhance the walkable island lifestyle. Perfect for an investment property, seasonal home or year round residence, this is an incredible offering! The home next door at 11546 Laika Lane is available for purchase as well. With two contiguous properties in this amazing location, there is unbelievable potential!

11550 Laika Lane, Captiva
$1,350,000
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 2026026981 MLS
Only three houses from the incredible beach of Captiva, this quaint cottage sits near the end of a private shell drive. This is beach living at its easiest. The open living area is ready to be transformed into a fabulous living space with high ceilings adjacent to the existing screened front porch and an open deck accessible from the kitchen and living area. Two en suite bedrooms finish the space, one of which includes access to a private screened porch. Currently down to studs, this home is ready for a new owner to create a fabulous beach house in this amazing location. The shops and restaurants of the Captiva Village are within short walking distance. The home next door at 11550 Laika Lane is available for purchase as well. With two contiguous properties in this Captiva Beach location, there is unbelievable potential!

11546 Laika Lane, Captiva
$78,400
2026010425 MLS
GREAT OPPORTUNITY on North Captiva Island! Fabulous Building Lot! Best-priced lot on the Central South Side of the Island AND located directly across from The Island Club at North Captiva (approximately 150 yards). This residential lot sits in a Desirable Area on the Island with a Very Short Walk to the Ferry, The Island Club at North Captiva, and all the amenities it has to offer. Lush and tropical, this is your chance to own a Piece of Paradise! Close to Butterfly Beach and a Short Distance to the Island's beautiful beaches and amenities. Come and Explore all that North Captiva Island has to Offer! Ferry services run all day, every day. Visit our Gorgeous Beaches and enjoy Amazing Fishing and Shelling. Drive a Golf Cart, Rent a Fat Tire Bike, or Walk the State Preserve while Admiring the Birds, Tortoises, Eagles, Manatees, Dolphins, and other Wildlife and Marine Life! Island Amenities include the Boats and Fun Store, Mango's Convenience Store, Mango's Outdoor Grill and Bar, the new Anchorage Steak House, the new Coconuts Outdoor Bar, The Island Club Gift Store, Mainstay Indoor and Outdoor Restaurant, Mainstay's Ice Cream and Gift Shop, Barnacle's Bar, and Over the Waterfront Restaurant at Safety Harbor.

516 Longboat Circle, Captiva
$1,650,000
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 2025024701 MLS
Over the years, one of the most popular weekly vacation rental homes on Captiva has had an exceptional rating by VRBO guests. 2027 advance rentals are already booked well into the summer months. This classic Captiva cottage-style home is totally updated with new LVP flooring, two new baths, a new quartz kitchen with new S/S appliances, and a separate laundry room. The home is well furnished for guest comfort, with 3 TVs, a living room audio system with Bose speakers, and speakers on the pool deck. The French doors from the living room and full-length screened lanai lead to the 2024 resurfaced 26 x 13 electric heated pool. All windows are impact-rated, installed by StormSmart in 2021. The pool cage is new (2023), the pool heater is new (2025), the A/C is new (2021), and the W/H is new (2023). A spacious, separate outdoor storage shed sits on the rear corner of the property for beach equipment. Beach access is a 3-5 minute walk to the path by the Library and Chapel by the Sea. The Green Flash Restaurant is a 1-minute walk, and the village center is a 5-minute walk. Due to busy weekly guest occupancy, showings will be accepted by appointment only on Saturdays between 12 and 2 p.m., between guest turnovers. Future guest reservations after closing must be honored. Any advance or final rental payments shall be credited to the buyer at closing. The requested closing date is no earlier than January 1, 2027.

11510 Murmond Lane, Captiva
$1,790,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 2025024676 MLS
The popularity of this 3/3 Key West-style home, the Sun & Moon, may place it in the top tier of Captiva rental houses, with over 100 VRBO guests rating it as exceptional. It is easy to maintain and prepare for incoming guests. Early 2027 advance reservations are booked into April, and many are multi-year repeat guests. The house is very well furnished and equipped for guest or owner's use. The metal roof was replaced in 2020. StormSmart installed new impact windows in 2021, and the heated pool has been resurfaced. To avoid disturbing guests, showing requests can only be approved on Saturdays between departing and incoming guests, with 12 to 2 pm suggested. Closing date not requested before January 1, 2027. Future guest reservations must be honored. Any advance or final rental payments for reservations shall be credited to the buyer at closing.

11506 Wightman Lane, Captiva
$233,000
2025015126 MLS
Discover your slice of paradise on North Captiva Island! ?? This vacant lot is just a short walk to a pristine, untouched beach and charming island restaurants. Accessible only by boat or small plane, North Captiva offers unmatched privacy and natural beauty. Enjoy the island lifestyle where golf carts are the primary mode of transportation — the perfect spot to build your dream coastal retreat!

4500 Oyster Shell Drive, Captiva